| Rabbi Mayer Hirsch and Rabbi Gershon Katzman | 1908-1930 |
| Rabbi J. A. Goldberg | 1930-1931 |
| Rabbi Morris Fischel | 1941-1949 |
| Rabbi Aaron Werner | 1949-1952 |
| Rabbi Joseph Greenberg | 1953 |
| Rabbi Stanley Wexler | 1954-1958 |
| Rabbi Alfred Fructer | 1959-1962 |
| Rabbi Louis Tuchman | 1963-1965 |
| Rabbi Harold Gottesman | 1966-1968 |
| Rabbi Malcolm Sparer | 1969-1972 |
| Rabbi David Thaler | 1973-1976 |
| Acting Rabbi Samuel Hirsch | 1977-1984 |
| Rabbi Michael Samuel | 1984-1987 |
| Rabbi Sam Krasner | 1989-1992 |
| Rabbi Abraham Sultan | 1992-1996 |
| Rabbi Shlomo Zarchi | 1996-Present |
ב"ה